collection.jpegeBooks present some unique challenges to the “personality” of books, challenges that make me think there will yet be a very long life for pbooks, particularly hardcover pbooks.

I am a book collector. I am proud of owning, for example, an excellent first edition of Sinclair Lewis’ It Can’t Happen Here. I love my first editions of Steinbeck, Twain, and numerous other authors — some signed, most not – books that I canvassed used bookstores and online booksellers for over many years. I sometimes attend lectures by authors at the Franklin Roosevelt Presidential Library and purchase the authors’ books and have them sign them. I’m even on the list for one of the 1,000 autographed copies of former President George W. Bush’s forthcoming book.

As a collector, books hold special value to me. And being able to obtain a well-preserved first edition, first printing of books by well-known and well-appreciated authors is important to me. Although once I acquire a book for my collection, I do not part with it, many people view the books as investments and buy and sell them like stock. Me, I look forward to passing them down to my children and grandchildren with the hope that they will keep passing them on and never part with them.

I revere books because books are a source of knowledge, of entertainment, of civilization, of social connectedness. I value books because they can take me places I would otherwise never be able to go, see things that I would not otherwise ever see, learn things that I need to learn to be a better person. It is true that ebooks can do all these things for me, but ebooks, unlike pbooks, can’t be passed on, can’t give a sense of permanence, and literally have no value because they are infinitely reproducible and infinitely correctable (see eBooks and the Never-Ending Rewrite).

Collectible pbooks are collectible for many reasons, not just because of who is the author. pBooks are collectible for the quality of the artwork, the cover design, the fact that the first edition, first printing had an error in it that was corrected in subsequent printings, because the author signed it, because it is a first edition, first printing of which there were only a few hundred copies before the book took off, because collectors can literally own the pbook (a currently impossible task with ebooks), and because pbooks can have a special personality: the personalization of the book; the recording of when and why it was given/received; an author’s signing of it, making it stand out from other copies..

None of these attributes apply to ebooks. As we all know, an ebook is really a leased collection of digits. Amazon has already demonstrated how fungible ebooks are when it removed 1984 and Animal Farm, regardless of the validity of the reasons for the removal, from purchasers Kindles — something it could not have done with a pbook. And ebooks, at least in current form, are unlimited editions. Even if Apple declared that the centennial Dickens was a limited edition and therefore worth an extra $50 to lease, the limit is really unlimited because of the ease of reproduction. Plus we all know that Apple, Amazon, and Barnes & Noble — or any other publisher or seller — will fill consumer demand for an ebook rather than cut it off, which is something that cannot be done with a pbook — there is no such thing as an unlimited print run because of the cost.

Additionally, there is literally no way to autograph an ebook that adds value to it. Even if a “real” signature could somehow be planted on a bunch of digits, the fact that the digits could be remotely taken away under the licensing terms destroys the value of the signature. Would you pay extra to have your ebook digitally signed knowing that if you change from, say, a Kindle to a Sony device that the book is no longer accessible, or that if it is subsequently discovered that buried on page 210 the author accidentally included embarrassing, highly personal information that the already-leased copies could be remotely erased without your approval.

It should also be noted that because ebooks are leased, there is probably no requirement in the lease terms that a vendor-erased book be replaced with another copy.

This brings us to the second problem, which really puts the nail in the coffin of “personality.” One of the things that makes a book special is when it is received as a gift, and when that gift is specially inscribed, such as “Happy 12th birthday, John. Love, grandma Pearl.” Or when you meet your favorite author who personalizes a copy of his or her book for you.

These inscriptions give a book a special personality. And that personality not only remains special to the initial recipient, but can have a great deal of meaning to subsequent family generations or even to collectors or historians. It is not unusual for a collector or historian to come across a special inscription from an author or gift giver that gives an insight to a major historical person’s thinking and lead to new knowledge about that historically important person.

Alas, with ebooks, that personality dies. Again, the death has many causes, not least of which are the ephemerality of the digits and the limitations imposed on ebooks by digital rights management (DRM) schemes, leasing terms, and the inability to create a single, unalterable version.

With this in mind, I think pbooks will have a long life, even if they ultimately constitute a minority share of the book market.

A Postscript: The day after I wrote this article, the value of the inscribed pbook was again demonstrated to me: My family gave me a signed first edition copy of President Lyndon Baines Johnson’s The Vantage Point: Perspectives of the Presidency 1963-1969. Opening to the half-title page and seeing President Johnson’s signature was thrilling; I cannot imagine how that thrill could be duplicated with an ebook. LBJ’s signature adds to the “personality” of the book by making it more than just cold digits that are duplicable at will.

Editor’s Note: the above is reprinted, with permission, from Rich Adin’s An American Editor blog. PB


  1. As a recovering book-hoarder, I both identify with what Rich has to say here and have a very different perspective on the value. I’ve tried to see my collection as an asset to be handed down to my son but he makes it clear that a mass of wood pulp is about as valuable to him as would be my vintage collection of canned peas.

    There are plenty of people who collect LPs, valuing their attractive jackets, the liners, the possibility of band member signatures, but that doesn’t mean that pressed plastic discs are on their way back, it simply means that we collect old and pretty things. People also collect and value ancient Babylonian clay tablets but there isn’t much call for publishing on them any more.

    I’ve been wrong about when eBooks will replace pBooks, but I truly believe that new pBooks will be about as common as new LP albums by the end of the decade.

    Rob Preece

  2. I don’t know when it will happen, but I can see ebooks being a mass market replacement for pbooks someday. That doesn’t however mean it’ll eliminate pbooks entirely. Even a lot of hardcovers these days are more of a mass market product when compared to the quality of books from years past. I think the quality, and price, of these hardcovers will rise and they’ll become something mainly for collectors and certain bibliophiles. Kind of how LP’s are now (yes LPs are still released and sold), hardcovers will be a more limited release collectible item.

  3. The closest I ever came to being a hoarder was my pbooks. I felt like I couldn’t throw them away, or pass them on. I actually kept buying bookshelves to accommodate my collection until I ran out of space to put the shelves.
    I don’t think ebooks will ever become collectible, not just because they are licenced, because they aren’t tangible.

    For people who collect books, first editions or paperbacks, the ebook will eventually minimize their choices. Eventually.

    The things is, mostly people just want to read books, and ebooks make that easy and transportable.

  4. Rich, I think the mistake you are making here is assuming that this is a zero-sum game with either ebooks or print books ‘winning’ and wiping the other into oblivion. I think this is a false ssumption. When you talk about the market for collector books, this is a different sort of book than a $6.99 mass market paperbook of the newest Nora Roberts. Someone might read only ebooks and not prefer pbooks just because they are NOT a collector and will just read the books once and be done with them. Others may get some books in ebook and other in print—I still prefer my cookbooks in paper, and would never buy a children’s picture book in ebook, for example.

    I myself am a devout ebook reader simply because I read so much, I haven’t got the space to keep it in paper. But that does not mean I am anti-book or that I don’t appreciate the print book for certain situations. In fact I recently got hold of some children’s books that used to be at my grandmother’s house and I have special plans for them.

  5. I think paper books will always be collectible, and eventually they will become like a Matisse painting; auctioned for vast sums to the rich. I think this is just one part of the hyper-throw-away fixation of people. No one wants anything that can’t be thrown away or upgraded. This sort of consume and throw away has really taken off in the digital age.

  6. It seems to me that “leased” pertains only to DRM books. Non-DRM books are kept, transferred to new readers (kind of like taking a print book and moving it to a new room or a new house). Also, because you think that an e-book cannot have a signature of the author that is personalized to a particular person does not mean that it cannot contain a digitized signature of the author, because many books do have signatures. I guess you prefer to be the only one with a signed book? Perhaps having all the books with signatures somehow “cheapens” the book, but only to a collector. To the other 99% of us it doesn’t matter. Also, I think the ability to add a personalized copy of an author’s signature to an e-book should be a trivial matter or at least not a significant one. Please, consider the e-book as just another way to read, just like Hard Cover, paperback, trade, penny dreadful, magazine or whatever mode the story appears in. Technology marches on.

  7. Author signatures in your books usually mean only that someone was prepared to stand in line at a bookshop for somewhere between a few minutes and a few hours in order for a brief encounter with celebrity; or to pay lots of money for a book to somebody else who was. Either way, it’s merely a symptom of having way too much time and/or money on your hands. The cult of authorship is one of the more irrational manifestations of the whole mad publishing business, and the sooner it is dismantled the better.

  8. A minor technicality. Ebooks (for the most part) are not leased, they’re licensed. The book is yours to read, quote from, parody, etc. You just can’t sell it to someone else under the terms of most licenses. One of the big questions is what do the limits of the licenses mean. Issues like obsolescence of DRM, archival copies, format shifting, market value and fair pricing for a restricted good, etc. are yet to be determined. For example, can my son inherit my ebooks? That’s not a sale and it doesn’t require copying.

    I have a few books, both paper and electronic I value for a variety of reasons. Some of them are signed. Most of the others are about as valuable and premanent as a fishwrapper.

    Jack Tingle

The TeleRead community values your civil and thoughtful comments. We use a cache, so expect a delay. Problems? E-mail